Zombie Science image for IDTF
Zombie Science
ID the Future Intelligent Design, Evolution, and Science Podcast
Episodes
Share
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email

Biologist Jonathan Wells Offers a Cure for Zombie Science

Episode
1867
With
Andrew McDiarmid
Guest
Jonathan Wells
Duration
00:17:52
Download
Audio File (8.6 mb)
Share
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Flipboard
Print
Email

On this ID the Future from the vault, Zombie Science author and biologist Jonathan Wells and host Andrew McDiarmid explore the seductive but misleading appeal to consensus science. This is when someone makes a bandwagon appeal to support a scientific hypothesis rather than offering evidence and arguments—as in, “All serious scientists agree that X is the case.” Wells says history makes hash of the consensus-science appeal because the history of scientific progress is all about a consensus view being overthrown by a newer, more accurate view that for a time was a minority view.

Wells also draws a distinction between evidence-based empirical science and ideologically driven science. The example he gives for the latter? Scientific materialism. Instead of a search for truth about the natural world, science under scientific materialism becomes a search for the best materialistic explanation for this or that phenomenon. Mix scientific materialism and consensus science and you get what Wells has described as “Zombie Science.”

Wells and McDiarmid also discuss the problem of science journalism hype. Most scientific discoveries are small, incremental findings of little interest to the general public. The solution for many science journalists: hype the small finding into something earth-shattering. As a remedy, Wells encourages a modest dose of skepticism any time one is reading a science article in the popular press. What about the claims of Darwinists that the science “is settled,” that evolution “is a fact,” and that bad design in biology proves an evolutionary mechanism, not intelligent design? Here, Wells encourages more than a modest dose of skepticism, and gives the example of the supposed “backward wiring of the vertebrate eye” as a case in point.

Dig Deeper

  • Haven’t read Zombie Science, the follow-up to Dr. Wells’s classic Icons of Evolution? Now’s your chance!